HD: Horrid Duplicate or Handy Design? - PART 1

The new trend of rereleasing their work with a shiny HD sticker.

By Daavpuke, Posted 17 Sep 2010

High Definition has already set in a while ago. Most people love the addition of watching things in advanced resolutions and that’s all dandy for them. Movies have long since picked up on the matter and started releasing their work, or rereleasing it even, to be viewed in this circumstance. Again, it’s an understandable move. Movies have a key feature in how their visuals come across and thus updating this illustration enhances the whole experience. But now games have also come into the trend of rereleasing their work with a shiny HD sticker. This is a somewhat lesser understandable move.

Recently, it was announced they were going to bring out Team Ico games once more; specifically Ico and Shadow Of The Colossus. This followed the HD release of God Of War. There are also rumors for a Sly Cooper update, Odin Sphere and Muramasa: The Demon Blade, amongst many others being whispered through at the local water cooler. In fact, Sony is already so adamant on the success of the venture, they’ve started using box art with the subtitle “Classics HD”.  So, it’s safe to assume many other older games are on route to take a second bow. But why is that? What is so fundamentally flawed about the games that they need to be remade? Nothing is wrong with the games; they’re just being made to look shinier and new again.  But that’s good, right? Bright new shiny game, what could be wrong with that?

Classic HD Sly Raccoon

It's coming, might as well get used to it...

The main aspect of a game is still the part where you can play or ‘game’ with the product, therefore having the term gameplay. If its key feature was to merely look at it, it would be an interactive movie, Kojima. So, the part where you pick up a controller (or not now) and go about the fictional area of the world is the part of the game you should focus on. A high definition release doesn’t really touch that part. It spruces up your characters and background, maybe heightens the framerate, but it leaves the game aspect as it is and as it was.  So actually, you’ll be playing the same game or an old game if you haven’t before; but it will be the same experience as years before, when it was thrown into the savage game market. The rerelease doesn’t add anything to an already existing product; it’s all cosmetics. So where is the point in playing something old that already is exists in the exact same state?  There isn’t really a point to it, but it’s worse than simple redundancy I’m afraid. I could fathom people wasting their own time; far be it for yours truly to dictate how people piss away their pointless time, looking at shiny objects.

OMG SHINY!

The fact is a HD release takes up time, effort and resources, just like all other work in life. Luckily, all the major prep work is already done, so the only thing left to do is polish up the silverware or maybe give it the ol’ spit shine. But it is essentially repeating the same work once over. Allow me to demonstrate (please take into account this is fiction):

A professional company holds a qualified team of 20 people. These people work on games, on any aspect their respective fields contain. From making games, to illustrating artwork, to doing PR, etc; they all have their job to do and do so well.

Now, this company feels it can take on 3 projects with its team. On one end, they have 12 people working on a large multi-platform title.  Then they have 5 people working on a handheld title. The remaining 3 people have been told to prepare the newest HD release. Seventeen people are now working on different material. Three people are revising and tweaking old stuff, which might not even be their own, such as BluePoint Games and God Of War. This basically wastes the time of 3 people capable of either aiding their colleagues or creating something novel themselves. Instead, they’re busy doing the work that has already been finished and released and passing it off as if it were something new, which is just lazy.

Let’s say Level 5 is working its men (and women, you feminist trolls) on releasing the amazing, upcoming Ni No Kuni. The gross amount is working to release the PS3 version in Q2 of 2011. The smaller team is prepared to finish the DS version on December 9, 2010 (that one is actually correct). The 3 remaining people are reworking Team Ico’s ventures. These 3 people could’ve spent time on helping Ni No Kuni getting here as well. There’s no point in them creating Ico; that game is already available, it’s here, it’s done, move on. With their aid, who knows, Ni No Kuni DS could’ve gotten here by December 9, 2010!

 Wait what; that’s the exact same date? Well of course it is; like mentioned these are professionals. They’ll take on projects they feel they can finish within in an allotted time. This isn’t Daikatana, where Romero spent so much time shouting random things, it basically ruined him. Well, except if you don’t count going away from Ion Storm, the creators of Deus Ex, to go work for LOLapps in the end, the creators of Critter Island. My point here is that their talent is ‘wasted’ on doing something already done, instead of helping to create novel work. Not only that, but someone is sinking funds into old material, bringing in resources and space. Three months spent shining up graphics, a hundred thousand dollars in man hours for the project, 3 office cubicles allotted towards making the release, it’s all for naught. This in the end is harmful to gamers wanting games.

OH HAI

Imagine all the people...

Note that harmful is in the most indirect and feeble way possible. The developers aren’t coming to your home, to destroy your previous copies of games and cutting you up with the shards. But compare it to someone coughing next to you, without having the courtesy to holding his hand up. This act of lazy opportunism may not do much against you; it’s not even a direct attack to your person or anything meant to be harmful. But because that person chose to be lazy and not have the effort of holding up his hand, your immune system gets to deal with germs and you could get sick; be it ever so slight. A High Definition release is like a cough in the face; not the end of the world but it’s a bit rude and it might smell a bit, you lazybones.

*To be continued*

Daav Valentaten, NoobFeed.

comments powered by Disqus

  • try to look at the bright side. games like Ico and Shadow of the Colossus are really rare, and being the masterpieces they are, they deserved a second chance. and while at it, why not make it prettier, fix the framerate (SotC) and add the ending the devs had intended but was cut from the NA version (Ico)?



    they also charge less for those games. it's a win-win relation. people that didn't get to experience the games before, didn't have them (me) or just want it once more get a chance to do it, and the makers get some money for the "fan service".



    and there's the nintendo way: not only give the graphics a slight revamp (not HD, but it's still an improvement) and give it wii controls. the metroid prime games were absurdly benefited from the retake, both graphically and in terms of gameplay.


    Posted Sep 17, 2010

  • I honestly dont mind HD releases...what i do prefer is Remakes of older titles...say Chrono Trigger, Tales of Phantasia (the one translated by Dejap translations...not the americrap one) and maybe even Breath Of Fire 1, 2 and 3! HD wont do for those titles...but hey who knows.


    Posted Sep 17, 2010
  • avatar RON


    If it’s an exact copy of the old game, then I’m not really up for the shiny stuff. But then again, games which I really loved playing long time before and still want to play them, I’d prefer the HD if it exists.


    Posted Sep 18, 2010

  • I don't care about it really. Where is the time to play old games?


    Posted Sep 18, 2010

  • @Amaya, i resent that! i really enjoy classi games over new ones (COD and Halo do not apply to this) so i always find time for them :)


    Posted Sep 20, 2010

Click here to view All

Lords of the Fallen Coming to Android and iOS

18 Dec 2014

The team behind Lords of the Fallen announced via Twitter that the action RPG w

DMC: Devil May Cry and Devil May Cry 4 Definitive Editions Announced

15 Dec 2014

The Definitive Edition of DMC: Devil May Cry is set to release on Xbox One and

CD Projekt RED Reveals The Second Playable Character For The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

15 Dec 2014

CD Projekt RED has confirmed today the second playable character in their upcom

Path of Exile Receives a PvP Overhaul

13 Dec 2014

Update 1.3.0 for Path of Exile features many new PvP features including new Cha

NoobFeed Feature

Platform(s): Xbox 360, PS3, PC, WII, 3DS, Vita, Mobile
Publisher(s): NoobFeed
Developer(s): NoobFeed Stuff
Genres: N/A
Themes: N/A
Release Date: 2009-02-14

/100