Gamefly is GO!

Ok I got Gamefly and I loaded down my Q. There are so many games I filled it up and still there are more I wish I could add to it. But anyway now its time to figure out which I wish to play first. I am mainly looking at renting 360 games, with little replay value and short(er) campaigns. But there are some good PS3 games I wanna get too but I want most of the multiplatform games on 360. Here are my top 360 picks. Now which do you think is best to rent first. I am renting The Saboteur and Star Wars the Force Unleashed first unless they can send Alan Wake but chances are low. So after those games should I get:

1. Call of Juarez: Bound in Blood (360)
2. Halo Wars
3. Assassin’s Creed 2 (360)
4. Halo ODST
5. Left 4 Dead
6. Batman Arkum Asylum (PS3)
7. Uncharted 2 Amoung Thieves
8. Prince of Persia (PS3)
9. Brutal Legend (360)
10. Darksiders (360)
11. Gears of War 2

These are just the ones I want to pick up first. They are in no particular order other than how I copied and pasted them. :P So which would YOU rent first?