GTA 6 Review Scores Spark Debate Over Performance and Critics

Rockstar's latest release breaks review records, but its 30 FPS performance, review credibility, and Game of the Year eligibility are drawing criticism.

News by Elme Dhee on  Nov 20, 2026

For years, Nintendo’s classic title The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time stood unchallenged as the highest-rated video game on Metacritic. Now, Grand Theft Auto 6 has officially shattered that long-standing record. Notably, GTA 6 achieved this impressive feat with a significantly larger volume of reviews factored into its aggregate score, marking another major milestone for Rockstar Games’ release.

GTA 6 has garnered an extraordinarily high wave of universal acclaim, boasting 156 critic reviews compared to Ocarina of Time's original 22. While additional incoming reviews could still slightly shift the final Metascore over time, the current consensus has already sparked widespread debate across the gaming community regarding whether the blockbuster sequel truly deserves its historic top placement.

GTA 6 Jason Lucia with Their Hands Up

Some questions remain about the legitimacy of the reviews.

But some players have questioned how consistently critics review major releases, despite the overwhelmingly positive reception. Online discussions have pointed to reviews that supposedly mention bugs, glitches, performance problems, writing failings, or gameplay issues but still give GTA 6 a perfect score.

These criticisms have breathed new life into the conversation about the relationship between review scores and the experience of playing a game. Nevertheless, inconsistencies between the written criticism and the numerical scores do not prove reviewers were pressured or that they deliberately inflated the scores.

Concerns raised about GTA 6's 30 FPS performance.

Performance is one of the big points of contention around GTA 6. On consoles, the game aims for 30 FPS, and players have voiced concerns about how consistently it maintains that frame rate on the base PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S. Reports suggest the PlayStation 5 Pro has been a notable exception.

Many gamers are disappointed that there is no option for 60 FPS, especially after years of talk about performance improvements in the current console generation. Some of these technical decisions may stem from Rockstar's visual ambitions, but modern hardware should still deliver a smoother experience, as players expect.

Performance may be taking a backseat to visual fidelity.

The talk about GTA 6 has also brought up bigger questions about the future of console gaming. Some players feel the devs are focusing more on graphical improvements, environmental detail, and visual fidelity than on consistent performance, perhaps abandoning 60 FPS as a baseline in favor of an optional luxury.

This fear extends beyond Rockstar's new game. If big games keep pushing for more detailed environments and struggle to maintain smooth frame rates, players may start asking whether the graphical improvements are worth the trade-offs. GTA 6 has thus become part of a larger discussion about player expectations of modern console hardware.

GTA 6 Jason and Lucia Holding Hands

The biggest debate around GTA 6 still isn't settled.

Although GTA 6 has now overtaken The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time in review scores, that does not mean the debate over which is better is settled. I mean, Ocarina of Time is still influential because of its historic value, innovation, and industry impact. All of which can not be quantified by review averages.

GTA 6 is too new to have the same long-term cultural legacy. Its impact will be determined by how players remember it years from now, how much it changes the industry, and whether its innovations remain relevant. A record-breaking score will guarantee its immediate success, but its lasting reputation will take time to build.

The Game Awards nominations add fuel to the fire.

There's also been debate about where GTA 6 should fit in the Game of the Year conversation, particularly for games released close to the nomination window. Its inclusion alongside titles such as 007: First Light, Control: Resonant, Phantom Blade Zero, Resident Evil: Requiem, and The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time intensified the discussion.

The nominations have also raised questions about whether remakes should compete with all-new releases. Some feel remakes should win awards for improving on existing games, while others feel awards should go to original experiences. The rows have added yet another layer to the overall argument over this year's contest. 

GTA 6 deserves a Game of the Year nomination. Despite criticism of its performance, review scores, and eligibility, GTA 6 remains one of the strongest contenders in the Game of the Year conversation. Few releases can match its enormous scale, technical ambition, and wide critical reception.

But the conversation is about more than its record-breaking Metacritic score. Players still debate whether the technical compromises are acceptable, whether reviews call out those flaws enough, and how the game will fare in the long run against other big releases. GTA 6 may be long gone, but the debate about its legacy rages on.

Elme Dhee

Editor, NoobFeed

Related News

No Data.