GTA 6 User Reviews Spark Debate Over Metacritic's Rating System

Despite receiving a near-perfect critic score, GTA 6 faces a wave of extreme user ratings, raising questions about review bombing and the credibility of online feedback.

News by Elme Dhee on  Nov 22, 2026

The reliability of user reviews has been ignited by a bitter debate surrounding Grand Theft Auto 6, as Metacritic shows more than 58,000 ratings, which present a very different picture from professional critics. The game got a near-perfect score from reviewers, but the user score is 5.6, a huge split between the two groups of people.

Metacritic currently lists GTA 6 with an impressive critic score of 99 based on 152 professional reviews. However, audience sentiment tells a vastly different story, with the user score sitting at just 5.6 across roughly 58,121 submissions. Specifically, 49% of players left positive ratings, while 44% submitted negative reviews, leaving only a small fraction remaining neutral.

GTA 6 Jason Lucia Robbing a Store

However, questions remain about whether the negative ratings reflect real dissatisfaction or a concerted effort to hurt the game's reputation, since professional reviews differ from player feedback. Some of the criticism seems reasonable, but with so many extreme scores, it is hard to know how representative the overall rating is.

Extreme reviews call into question player feedback.

Several user reviews give GTA 6 perfect ten or zero scores with little explanation. Positive feedback, for example, applauds its visuals, immersive world and gameplay. At the same time, negative reviews usually target its 30 FPS performance, price, technical issues, and perceived changes to the usual GTA mechanics.

Other submissions seem to focus on personal issues with the story and characters, not the gameplay itself. Some reviews even make contradictory statements, like complaining about performance without understanding the difference between a targeted frame rate and one that's consistently maintained.

The GTA 6 versus Zelda rivalry adds more fuel to the fire.

The constant arguing over GTA 6 has unexpectedly dragged The Legend of Zelda into the crossfire. Some players have accused Zelda fans of intentionally tanking GTA 6’s rating on review sites. In retaliation, others have fought back by submitting negative reviews on competing titles, turning the whole situation into a messy, escalating online fanboy war.

This manufactured rivalry has only added to the confusion, transforming two separate evaluations of entirely different games into an unnecessary competition. Players can easily appreciate both franchises on their own merits without pitting them against each other. Ultimately, arguing over their relative quality is no excuse to artificially manipulate or game their respective user scores.

GTA 6 Jason

Extreme ratings tend to drown out any valid criticism.

But not all negative reactions stem from poor-quality submissions. Some players have complained about GTA 6's slower pace, performance, and mission structure. The game's long introduction and immersive nature may not suit everyone, and complaints about these design choices are fully justified.

But giving a game a zero because of a specific mechanic or personal disagreement makes it harder for other players to see the real pros and cons. Similarly, a 5-star review with no substantive information about why the experience is worthwhile is not very helpful.

Metacritic's user score is facing questions about its credibility.

The controversy highlights a larger issue with user review systems that allow single stars to carry significant weight without requiring detailed justifications. Metacritic is a place where players can share their opinions, but today's situation shows how quickly extreme opinions can overtake more moderate ones.

At the end of the day, GTA 6's 5.6 user score doesn't necessarily reflect how the larger player base feels. With thousands of submissions ranging from glowing praise to unsupported criticism, potential players may need to look beyond the overall rating and read more detailed reviews before forming their own opinions.

Elme Dhee

Editor, NoobFeed

Related News

No Data.