Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | Kill or Spare Arnold Outcome
Here’s a guide to the outcomes if you decide to kill or spare Arnold in Grand Theft Auto 6.
Game Guide by Ragib Rawnak on Nov 22, 2026
GTA 6 hands you one of its first permanent choices early in Chapter 1. At the end of the Hey Arnold! mission, Jason has a gun pointed at Arnold, and you have to decide whether he lives or dies.
It might look like a quick moment, but this choice sticks. It changes Jason's Criminal Profile, and it decides whether Arnold shows up again later in the story. Here's what happens with each option and which one is worth picking in Grand Theft Auto 6.
How the Kill or Spare Arnold Choice Happens
Arnold is Brian's broker, and he's not happy about how things went with the Kingfishers. After Brian and Cal track him down on Maroon Key, he makes a run for it. You chase him in Brian's truck, then on foot, until you finally corner him at the end of a dock outside Jason's house.
Brian's orders are pretty loose. He just wants Arnold to keep his mouth shut, however that happens. When you reach the end of the dock, Jason pulls out his pistol, and Arnold drops to his knees and tries to explain himself.
Hold L2/LT when the prompt shows up to make your choice. If you want the option to spare him, you'll need to Focus on Arnold first.

What Happens If You Kill Arnold
If you shoot Arnold, Jason gets a Hardened rating on his Criminal Profile. This one act doesn't make Jason a lost cause, but it does push him toward the ruthless end of the scale. And that matters for more than just story flavor, because your Criminal Profile affects how Jason builds Focus.
Killing Arnold also cuts him out of the game for good. You won't see him again, and you'll miss anything tied to him later in the story in Grand Theft Auto 6.
What Happens If You Spare Arnold
If you let Arnold go, he promises to stay quiet, jumps into the water, and swims off. Once he's in the water, the game won't let you shoot him, so there's no changing your mind.
Sparing him gives Jason a Restrained rating, which keeps him on the more controlled, professional side of the Criminal Profile.
And here's where it pays off. In Chapter 4, Brian runs into Arnold again and forgives him for what happened. As thanks for letting him retire in peace, Arnold sends you $10,000. That's a solid chunk of money, and you only get it if he's still alive.
What Happens If You Do Nothing
You don't have to pick at all. If you wait too long, Arnold says he's just going to leave, then jumps off the dock and swims away on his own. This plays out much like sparing him, and the cutscene after the mission stays the same.
Does Your Choice Change the Chapter 1 Story?
Not right away. No matter what you do on the dock, the scene that follows is the same. Jason joins Brian at his place for drinks and tells him Arnold won't be talking. Brian then introduces Jason to his friend Kenton, and they talk about treasure hunting. This unlocks the next Chapter 1 mission, Island Dreams.
So there's no instant penalty either way. The real effects show up in your Criminal Profile and later in the story.
Should You Kill or Spare Arnold?
For most players, sparing Arnold is the better choice. You get the Restrained rating, you keep him around for later, and you get $10,000 in Chapter 4. Money is tight early on, so that payout helps in Grand Theft Auto 6.
But if you're going for a more ruthless Jason, killing Arnold fits that playthrough. Just know you're giving up the money and any future scenes with him. One kill won't lock you into a dark path, so you still have room to shift your profile later.

FAQ
Q. Is killing Arnold permanent in GTA 6?
A. Yes. Once Arnold is dead, he's gone for good, and you lose any future interactions with him, including the Chapter 4 payout.
Q. How do you get the $10,000 from Arnold?
A. Spare Arnold at the end of Hey Arnold! Later, in Chapter 4, Brian forgives him, and Arnold sends you $10,000 for letting him retire.
Q. Can you shoot Arnold after he jumps in the water?
A. No. Once Arnold hits the water, the game won't let you shoot him.
Also, check our Grand Theft Auto VI Review and other guides below:
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Beginner’s Guide | Gameplay Tips & Tricks
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Get Sacrifice Ending
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Get Best Ending
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Upgrade Weapons
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Improve Jason & Lucia's Romantic Relationship
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Do Stealth Takedowns
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Fast Travel
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Steal Cars
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Get Key Cloner
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Increase Focus
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Increase Stamina
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Get Secret Endings
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Get the Swamp Ending
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | All Endings Explained & How to Get Them
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | Say Nothing or Saved Cash Outcomes
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Open & Manage a Bank Account
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Upgrade Vehicles
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Repair Vehicles
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Customize Lucia
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Customize Jason
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Lose Cops
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | All Machine Guns and How to Get Them
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Improve Your Criminal Profile
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Easily Make $20,000 Early On
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Keep Stolen Guns
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | How to Make a Stolen Car Your Own
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | All Sniper Rifles and How to Get Them
- Grand Theft Auto 6 | Early Game Guns Guide
- Grand Theft Auto 6 | Early Game Money Guide
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | All Shotguns and How to Get Them
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | All Sidearms and How to Get Them
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | All Assault Rifles and How to Get Them
- Grand Theft Auto 6 Guide | All Tactical Rifles and How to Get Them
Senior Editor, NoobFeed
Latest Articles
No Data.
