Assassin's Creed Black Flag Resynced Guide | How to Assassinate Benjamin Hornigold

Here’s a guide on how to assassinate Benjamin Hornigold in Assassin's Creed Black Flag Resynced.

Game Guide by Ragib Rawnak on Jul 19, 2026

The Murder and Mayhem memory in Assassin's Creed Black Flag Resynced can give you a hard time if you try to fight everyone head-on. In this main story mission, your goal is to find and assassinate Benjamin Hornigold.

By taking a specific stealth route, you can bypass most of the danger, secure a convenient checkpoint, and take out the boss with a single hit. Here is how it works.

Coastline Navigation and Checkpoint Access

The search begins far from the coastline of Santanillas Island. You will need to navigate the waters and head inland. Follow the natural trail over the terrain while avoiding the attention of the local guards in Assassin's Creed Black Flag Resynced.

Keep walking up into the ruins, and you will find a part with a big palm tree on your right-hand side. This spot confuses a lot of players, and it is easy to get lost here. Look around, and you will see a group of guards patrolling the high ground.

Here is the thing: this is the only part of the mission where you do not need to worry about being stealthy. Go ahead and eliminate all the guards in this immediate area.

Once you clear them out, the game will automatically give you a checkpoint. This saves your progress so you do not have to start from the beach if you mess up later.

How to Assassinate Benjamin Hornigold in One Hit

Look to the west from your position at the checkpoint. You will see a small, separate island nearby. Benjamin Hornigold is located right there on that structure. There is only one specific path that connects your current location to his island in Assassin's Creed Black Flag Resynced.

Once you begin crossing over to the target's island, you must drop back into stealth mode immediately. Do not let the guards spot you.

If you manage to sneak all the way up to Benjamin Hornigold without triggering open conflict, you can perform a stealth assassination.

This lets you kill him in one hit, allowing you to completely skip the actual boss fight and finish the Murder and Mayhem quest quickly in Assassin's Creed Black Flag Resynced.

FAQ

Q. Can you kill Benjamin Hornigold with a pistol?

A. No. To get the optional objective and ensure a quick kill, you should use your hidden blades for a stealth assassination from above or behind.

Q. What happens if the guards spot me on the final island?

A. If the guards detect you, Benjamin Hornigold will engage you in a standard boss fight. He will counter your basic attacks, making the encounter much longer and more difficult. If you get spotted, you can let yourself desynchronize to reload the checkpoint you got near the palm tree.

Also, check our Assassin's Creed Black Flag Resynced Review and other guides below: